top of page

Thoughts about the Zionism is Racism motion

Oct 24
6 min read

Updated: Oct 28

On October 9th, I sent subscribers the email below and it was viewed by over 2,900 people. It was all about the Green Party's motion of October 4th concluded that Zionism is Racism , and it got some interesting comments. Given the interest that the topic evoked I have decided to reproduce the email as a blog, below here, followed by a discussion of the comments.


Dear Subscriber (email of October 9th)

 

I previously drew attention to Richard Sanders' excellent video about Israeli interference in elections around the World. In this new video he made some strong points about the Green Party's Zionism is Racism motion.  



  • Sanders acknowledged that the motion distracted from the party's immediate priority of winning elections on bread-and-butter issues. 

  • However, the motion had the fundamental virtue of cutting through Zionist arguments that complicate and obfuscate what Israel has been doing in Palestine and the Middle East. By asserting that Zionism is Racism, the motion puts those defending Israel on the back foot, a vital change after the many years they have routinely tarred those who stand up for Palestinian rights with smears of antisemitism. 

  • The media coverage had been obscene. Sanders cited analysis of 15 reports from the BBC, newspapers and news agencies, by the independent data company NewsCord, showing that opponents of the motion were given nearly ten times more space than supporters. Newscord also noted that eight of the ten reports that quoted the motion's single-state clause stopped before the words equal rights for all.

     

You may also wish to consult Jonathan Cook's excellent article on the same topic saying that what's shameful is that no party before the Greens called Zionism racist.  


A flood of Zionist propaganda and media complicity has been vented against the proposers of the motion, the Green Party and Zack Polanski. Those supporting Palestine may be tempted to retract, and appease apologists for Zionism, much as Jeremy Corbyn did in the run-up to the 2019 election (see here, under the heading of Corbyn's own goals). But this is inadvisable. Those who question the wisdom of the proposers in bringing this motion at this particular time need to answer Richard Sanders' question: if not now, when? And we need to allow time for the message to sink in. 


Historical context helps us see the wood from the trees


Looking forward, we need to dispassionately discuss Zionist ideology with our fellow citizens in the light of other horrors of recent European history. Zionism fits a pattern of aggressive nationalism that emerged in several states in the late 19th and early 20th centuries. It has something in common with Serbian nationalism, which involved a series of atrocities and assassinations, especially that of Archduke Ferdinand which started the First World War. Viscious nationalism reemerged in the 1990s after the dissolution of Yugoslavia, infamously in the case of the Srebrenica massacre. And it also has something in common with the growth of German nationalism after World War I. These movements were nurtured by an acute sense of victimhood. For the Serbs this went back to the Ottoman invasion in the Middle Ages, and was subsequently fed by the expansion of Austro-Hungary into South Slav territories. In the case of the Germans, it rested on a punitive peace settlement - largely the work of the French President Clemenceau - in the Treaty of Versailles, and the search for convenient scapegoats (notably Jews).

 

Once a particular ethnic group sees itself as the victim of alien forces, it can use this to justify horrendous racist war crimes as a form of self-defence. We have seen this with these three ethnic groups, backed up, in the case of Israel by intensive brain-washing to persuade Jewish citizens that the persecution of Jews is not just a thing of the past, but another Holocaust in waiting.


We must patiently go on asserting the uncomfortable truth about Zionism


Few of us, if any, are born evil but, depending on the way we are brought up and socialised, we can easily embrace evil concepts. This is true of Serbs, Germans, Jews, British, Chinese or any group on the face of this planet. So when we say Zionism is racism, we call out the ideology that underlies the Israeli socialisation process and facilitates the commission of atrocities, not fundamental human beings who, when they enter this world, are much of a muchness.


A note on comments received


Seventeen people wrote in withr comments which were mainly positive. However, two people felt that, while agreeing with the sentiment behind the motion, it didn’t allow one to explore the context. One distinguished commentator said that

mere denunciation, without explanation of its underlying context, may actually be misleading if not counter-productive.


One Jewish antizionist felt he would have preferred a motion that referred more explicitly to what Zionism has become. He went on to say that:

Saying "Zionism is racism" may give the impression that you are saying the aspiration for a safe haven for Jews is racist. That possibility is of course what Zionist apologists have seized on to vilify the Green Party. 


However, as you will see from Naomi Wimborne-Idrissi’s recent JVL article other Jewish antizionists take the opposite view. She thinks:

The Greens need to double down or risk returning to irrelevance, leaving the establishment to become a debate club between the old behemoths and this new far-right phenomenon of fascism.


But most interestingly, two people felt that I had been unfair in comparing Serbian nationalism to Zionism. One of them pointed to the Croat regime during World War 2, that committed genocide against Serbs, Jews and Roma. As for the Serbs, he said

there may have been moments of claimed victimhood, but hardly to the extent of constituting a national characteristic..….. apart from the Sarajevo murders, which could be taken as a justifiable gesture against a provocation by the controlling power and led to a British-Serb alliance in WW1, what else do you have in mind that supports your Serb-Zion theory?


Of course, I had never claimed that Serbs were a unique example of European nationalism to which I could compare Zionism. Yes, the Catholic-fascist Croatian regime waged a genocidal campaign during World War II.


To answer these critics' other points I had to go back to source documents. As for victimhood, the Serbs' memory of their medieval defeat by the Ottomans in Kosovo and elsewhere figured large in their sense of having been the eternal victim. An internet search throws up a cornucopia of sources like this one, this one and this study of attitudes. The second source states that:

No figure better embodies the intellectual architecture of modern Serbian irredentism than Dobrica Ćosić, often called its spiritual father. In the late 20th century, amid the breakup of Yugoslavia, Ćosić declared that Serbs had become “the new Jews,” the victims of a unique historical persecution at the end of the century. He stated variations such as: “Anti-Serbism has replaced anti-Semitism. Serbs are the Jews of the late 20th century.”


As for what happened in the run up to World War I, I can cite the book: The Sleepwalkers; how Europe went to war in 1914, by Christopher Clark. He mentioned pre-World War I Serbian massacres on page 43-44. On p357, he mentioned the British Foreign Secretary, Grey, downplaying reports of these atrocities in newly conquered areas. According to Clark, Grey adopted a latently pro-Serbian policy in the negotiations at the London Conference of 1913 .... because he viewed the appeasement of Serbia as key to the durability of the Entente (i.e. the triple entente with France and Russia).

 

Clark also describes a particularly vicious and secretive organisation called the Black Hand which was responsible for the assassination of both the King of Serbia and Consort in 1903, and Archduke Ferdinand of Austro-Hungary in 1914. And as for the Sarajevo murders being as a justifiable gesture, I do not believe the Austro-Hungarian Empire was so despotic as to justify this sort of terrorism. 

 

I rest my case, there are clearly major differences, but the 20th century history of German, Serbian and Zionist nationalism illustrate how the aggression was fed by a sense of collective victimhood - often based on real events in the near and/or distant past where the ethnicity had suffered a raw deal.


Recent news


It is now three weeks since the Zionism is Racism motion, and we have seen a torrent of media condemnation. Notwithstanding, as can be appreciated in this BBC clip, it appears that Zack Polanski is holding his ground admirably, and is not folding before the taunts of interviewers like Laura Keunnsberg. Long may this last!



There has been endless media talk as to how the motion hurts the feelings of Jewish people but little attention has been paid to the perspective of the Palestinians who have suffered many decades of racist agression at the hand of Israel.


I therefore cite Ghada Karmi, a Palestinian lady born in 1940 and who in 1948 became one of the three quarters of a million refugees of Zionist aggression. She wrote an article called Of course Zionism is Racism; why the fuss? highlighting the furore with which the British establishment had reacted to the motion. She concludes that:

The Green party’s motion has begun the process of exploding these lies, and in so doing, it has laid the foundation stone for the dismantlement of Zionism and its spawn, the state of Israel. No other major western political party has ever had the courage to pass such a resolution.


We hope that the Greens stand firm, and do not crumble under the cumulative political and media pressure.

2 Comments


Elizabeth
Oct 25

It is reassuring that Green Councillors have published their letter in support of the Motion https://docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLScJetXC8iYYiNprP0wqkSovK7p9T8g8Fd5JSxoSAFZWFWi0-Q/viewform



Like
Jonathan Coulter
Oct 25
Replying to

That's a great letter

Like

Contact Us

Thanks for submitting!

bottom of page