Thrown under a bus - lasting injustice against a Chief Constable
Updated: 1 day ago
A senior police officer’s reputation was trashed when he tried to protect his community from racist thugs.
But the government misrepresented the decision as antisemitism.
It’s now a year since West Midlands Chief Constable Craig Guildford lost his job over a football match. And even in retirement he still faces charges of gross misconduct by the independent police watchdog.
Aston Villa was due to play Israeli team Maccabi Tel Aviv in November last year. But fans of the Israeli club are notorious for their violence and racist chanting.
West Midlands Police (WMP) had classified the match as high risk based on past behaviour of Maccabi fans.
In 2024 they attacked an Arab taxi driver – believed to have been Muslim – in Athens. The victim was hospitalised. In November that year, when they were in Amsterdam for a match with Ajax, they rampaged through the streets, attacking Dutch citizens with iron poles, as recorded by citizen journalist Annet de Graf. They are filmed chanting Death to Arabs and School’s out in Gaza because there are no children left” – a reference to the thousands of children slaughtered during the genocide.
And ahead of the match in Birmingham they were even banned in their native Israel. A derby between them and Hapoel Tel Aviv was cancelled in October last year after riots during which 15 people were injured and nine people arrested.
The government intervenes
But Home Secretary Shabana Mahmoud chose to see the ban as antisemitic, posting on X:
Antisemitism is a stain on our society that shames us all. Every football fan, whoever they are, should be able to watch their team in safety. This Government is doing everything in our power to ensure all fans can safely attend the game.
This is like putting a big sign on the outside of a stadium saying: 'No Jews allowed', she wrote.
She said she had no confidence in the chief constable – a statement which precipitated his resignation.
A report by government inspector Sir Andy Cooke said that West Midlands Police had been biased in banning the club’s supporters but that there was no evidence of antisemitism.
Muddied waters
Chief Constable Guildford was criticised because his report to Birmingham council’s Safety Advisory Group contained several inaccuracies – including the citing of a match between Maccabi and West Ham that never took place. Guildford said he had used AI and apologised profusely.
The affair was complicated not only by the shortcomings in the West Midlands Police report but also by the reporting of the fracas in Amsterdam.
The world’s media – including the BBC – reported that the Maccabi fans were the victims, not the perpetrators. But Ms de Graf's and a teenage vlogger’s footage proved the opposite.
The BBC never apologised to Ms de Graf for broadcasting a falsified version of her package it had not taken the trouble to check. In fact, only one TV station, in Germany, ever contacted her to say sorry.
Contradictory statements coming from the Dutch police further complicated matters.
Jews call out genocide in Gaza
Some members of Jewish Voice for Liberation (formerly Jewish Voice for Labour) wrote to West Midlands police commissioner Simon Foster criticising Sr Andy’s investigation into the affair.
Interviews had taken place with three Jewish groups but there was no mention of any consultation with Birmingham’s 350,000-strong Muslim community, they said, adding that Muslims in Birmingham outnumber Jews by 100 to one.
JVL spokesperson Prof David Mond acknowledged there had been discrepancies in the WMP’s report but regretted that the chief constable had been criticised purely on procedural grounds, saying:
While procedural failings should be attended to, the fact that the chief constable arrived at the correct decision surely should carry more weight.
After all, the Israeli Defence Force was and is still perpetrating an internationally acknowledged genocide against Palestinians in Gaza, and the Maccabi fans include many soldiers from the IDF.
Thrown under a bus
An independent MP Ayoub Khan, whose Birmingham constituency includes Villa Park where the match took place, said Guildford's retirement marked a dark and shameful chapter.
We've all just witnessed one of the biggest injustices of our time, he said.
A chief constable has been sacrificed not for gross misconduct in public office but for doing his job.
He added that Guildford had been thrown under the bus because he didn't conform to political pressure (see interview with Sky News).
The match took place as planned in the absence of the Israeli fans. The score was Aston Villa 2 Maccabi 0.



Comments